Solid Performance – The Best Fixed Blade Broadhead

Anthony Cote
Written by
Last update:

If you’re looking for something to make sure that your favorite deer meet their maker as quickly and humanely as possible, then you’re looking for the best fixed blade broadhead available.

Don’t worry though – we’re talking about a weapon! No need to go running to the animal rights brigade.

In this article, we’ll be looking at the best fixed blade broadhead — the ones that have the highest quality of materials like steel, aluminum, and carbide — and the ones that are built to fly better in the wind than any other heavy-duty blade.

What are the best crossbow hunting arrows?

Slick Trick Broadhead 1 1/8Best OverallSlick Trick Broadhead 1 1/8
Sinbadteck Hunting BroadheadsBudget PickSinbadteck Hunting Broadheads
QAD Exodus 100Gr NonbarbUpgrade PickQAD Exodus 100Gr Nonbarb

1. Slick Trick Broadhead 1 1/8

Our rating: 9 / 10

Slick Trick Broadhead 1 1/8

Check Price on Amazon

Scratches mean death when hunting for big game, and the Bluff Head provides hunters with a deadly, yet safe option.

The Bluff Head Scratch Guard uses a tri-lobe design made of surgical grade stainless steel to power through a big game animal. The stainless steel design also makes it easy to clean your broadhead so you always have a smooth, ready-to-use blade.

The best part is possibly the broadhead’s adaptability to different states. Thanks to its shorter, 1.8” blade, you can hunt with this broadhead in states where a 2” blade is illegal.

2. Sinbadteck Hunting Broadheads

Our rating: 8 / 10

Sinbadteck Hunting Broadheads

Check Price on Amazon


  • Durable and well-made
  • Broadhead screws on easily to an arrow
  • Comes in a pack of 12

The market for broadheads is great nowadays, and it’s really easy to get confused by so many types and brands. However, we’ve found that some of the best options for a crossbow are fixed blade heads because you don’t have to worry about tuning or fidgeting with weights.

3. G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead 3/pk.

Our rating: 7 / 10

G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead 3/pk.

Check Price on Amazon


  • Contain 3 sides so that it can adjust for wind
  • Great design that takes into account classic archery and hunting
  • Good weight for stabilizing
  • Great for Beginners
  • Affordable blades


  • Bigger profile
  • Not as sharp

G5 Outdoors Montec Broadhead is a great head for big game. It has a three blade design that will help you get the right flight of the arrow. It has a wide cutting blade that will let you take down even the most bulky animals.

It has been made to accommodate both archers and hunters alike. The entire head is made from stainless steel, which means that rust will not be an issue. This will help with the sturdiness of the equipment.

It has been designed with an incredibly strong ferrule that will let you keep it attached to your arrow even with the heaviest of animals. This is great for beginners who are still getting the hang of things.

4. Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead

Our rating: 7 / 10

Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead

Check Price on Amazon


  • arrow-shaped blades
  • barbed tip
  • 100 grain
  • easy replacement of blades without tools
  • durable
  • dependable


  • the blades can be difficult to clean
  • can be hard to get replacement blades
  • can be hard to remove the blades from the arrow

When it comes to getting the best performance from a broadhead, it is important to consider what animal you will be hunting. What is just right for a deer may not be the best for a turkey.

For deer, a good choice is the Muzzy Trocar. It is a reliable and multi-purpose broadhead with strong blades that deliver maximum penetration while still giving it a fairly wide cutting edge. The manufacturer recommends for these to be used on both one piece and mechanical arrowheads.

The blades are extremely durable, and it comes with an easy replacement of the blades without tools. This broadhead is also good for hunting other medium-sized animals such as hogs, coyotes, and wild boars.

5. QAD Exodus 100Gr Nonbarb

Our rating: 6 / 10

QAD Exodus 100Gr Nonbarb

Check Price on Amazon

Stainless steel extends the service life of this broadhead, which is something you don’t find with plastic and aluminum heads in the market. These heads won’t break and won’t melt.

Many QAD fixed-blade broadheads use fixed blades, but without the angle that target tip blades have. Because of this, they have better control in aiming than the target ones and they consume less power upon impact.

With 100 grains, these broadheads are really good when it comes to penetration. The Exodux 100gr fixed-blade broadheads are tough and can pierce through any type of bone.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the most accurate fixed blade broadhead?

The best way to choose your fixed blade broadhead for a particular animal is to take into account the speed that the animal and the arrow will have when they meet and consider the construction of the head.

Choose your speed-for-the-animal starting point. A slower-moving arrow and animal are easier to hit if you miss the vitals. A faster-moving arrow and animal are harder to hit if you miss the vitals. As a rule of thumb, you can use about one-third of the arrow's speed as a starting point.

What is the best fixed blade broadhead for elk?

Fixed blade broadheads are simple in that there are less moving parts to worry about. They are a good choice for people who are just starting out or for people who are in a hurry and don't want to spend time fiddling with the options and fine details you might find on a mechanical or expandable broadhead. Essentially, fixed blade broadheads are simple and you'll find that they are generally less expensive than expandables or mechanicals.

Compared to expandables or mechanicals (depending on your choice), fixed blade broadheads weigh less so you'll be able to carry additional arrows. They also penetrate better and fly flat since there are no protrusions or moving parts to cause wind resistance. Their simplicity means they are less likely to malfunction.

What is the deadliest Broadhead?

Broadheads are not guided missiles; it takes some practice to learn how to aim them properly and it takes some practice to learn how to fly them properly. There are many factors that influence how accurate these arrows fly, including: arrow weight, arrow spine, your grip, anchor point, sight pin alignment, etc. One of the easiest things you can do to improve your accuracy is to make sure your broadhead is properly balanced.

The point of balance on a broadhead is the pivot point where an arrow would balance if it were mounted on a string. Most experts agree that the optimal position for the point of balance is just before the blade where it begins to taper. For most head-to-head style heads this is around the 0.195 inch mark on a 100 grain head.

Are fixed blade or mechanical broadheads better?

Mechanical broadheads are definitely not as good as fixed blade broadheads in the world of bowhunting. Don't get me wrong, they are better than nothing and can be used to make the kill, but if you are looking for a better outcome for you and your game, look for a fixed blade broadhead.

I'll get more into the benefits of a fixed blade in a bit that explain why they are better, but one of the biggest differences between a mechanical and fixed blade head is their durability. A fixed blade has a sharp point that can be honed to a finer edge than a mechanical blade. This allows a fixed blade to stay sharper and maintain its edge longer while reducing the risk of dulling.

That is due in large part to the fact that they are usually manufactured with a thicker metal than a mechanical broadhead. A mechanical blade's blade never has a dull edge because it is fixed in its forward position and can't be sharpened.


We have pretty much tried to cover every conceivable situation when it comes to archery and want you to be able to understand the different situations and choose the best fixed blade broadhead. Each situation requires different Broadheads. Each game requires a different Broadhead and there are a few specialized situations you might find yourself in. Hopefully this guide has helped you understand the different situations and therefore the different Broadheads you will need.

Our Recommendation

Slick Trick Broadhead 1 1/8Best OverallSlick Trick Broadhead 1 1/8
Sinbadteck Hunting BroadheadsBudget PickSinbadteck Hunting Broadheads
QAD Exodus 100Gr NonbarbUpgrade PickQAD Exodus 100Gr Nonbarb