Fake it” with one of the Best Deer Decoys

Anthony Cote
Written by
Last update:

You may have heard that fake deer are one of the best and most effective ways to keep deer from eating your plants.

Are you ready to put the top deer repellents in practice to keep the deer away? Or at least to divert their attention away from your garden and your backyard where they will definitely eat all of your beloved flowers and plants?

If you are, but you’re not quite sure what exactly you need in order to keep these pesky deer away, just follow my advices and you will be able to protect your plants against them. Read on to find out and start saving your plants, bushes, and flowers.

I’ve prepared a list of the top ten deer repellents that helped me keep the deer away and save my garden from them. I hope you will find the best deer repellents on the list, and most importantly, that you should try them and benefit from them just like I did.

Here you will discover the best deer repellents for your garden.

NameCategoryProduct
MONTANA DECOY Dream Team Buck and DoeBest OverallMONTANA DECOY Dream Team Buck and Doe
MONTANA DECOY Miss MuleyBudget PickMONTANA DECOY Miss Muley
Flambeau OutdoorsUpgrade PickFlambeau Outdoors

1. MONTANA DECOY Dream Team Buck and Doe

Our rating: 9 / 10

MONTANA DECOY Dream Team Buck and Doe

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Camouflaged
  • 24-inch in length
  • Sturdy

The MONTANA DECOY Dream Team Buck and Doe Deer Decoys are a realistic and effective way to keep deer away from your garden, pond or any other hunting area.

The thick foam construction is completely safe for both humans and the wildlife, which makes this decoy set a necessity not only for hunters but also for nature-protection advocates.

Both the buck and doe decoy are made from high-quality foam and weigh about 2lbs each. These fake decoys are 1.8ft high when assembled and are a good addition to your garden animals.

2. MONTANA DECOY Miss Muley

Our rating: 7 / 10

MONTANA DECOY Miss Muley

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Nice smell of a doe
  • Can be used in different terrains and work for hours

You might have seen with your own eyes a spectacle of a doe fawn lying quietly, calling its mother for help and answers. Now you can have the same effect on the hunt through the use of a decoy. They are low tech, passive, and effective. And, when you have a deer decoy bagged, you have a possum that you can use to use for other things.

The Miss Muley decoy is one of the best deer decoys you can find as you can use it for hunting in a variety of terrains. It does not smell and is easy to use. It will attract deer until you shoot it.

3. Ultimate Predator Mule Deer Stalker Decoy

Our rating: 6 / 10

Ultimate Predator Mule Deer Stalker Decoy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Can be placed in various locations
  • Realistic design and texture

This decoy looks amazing and helps with the set up and tracking. If you want to keep your stakes low, this decoy does not require any batteries and can be placed where no other digital decoy can go. The decoy is 100% waterproof and works great on military land, private industrial sites and even residential neighborhoods.

If you’re ready to give your decoy a new look, the Ultimate Predator Mule Deer will also come with a replacement set of white coat, black coat and doe fawns.

The Ultimate Predator Mule Deer Stalker Decoy is fantastic for coyote hunting, although a similar digital decoy is more cost effective. Regardless, it’s a great tool to have in your arsenal.

4. Primos Scarface Decoy

Our rating: 6 / 10

Primos Scarface Decoy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Easy to use
  • Durable
  • Motion activated

So you want to know how to make a deer decoy? Here’s a great example of a deer decoy that will help you get the deer to come right to you. It’s versatile, too!

You can use it to keep the deer away from your valuable plants during the summer so you can enjoy a vegetable garden.

You can use it to bring deer to your hunting blind or tree stand.

5. Flambeau Outdoors

Our rating: 6 / 10

Flambeau Outdoors

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Large, strong blade
  • Affordable
  • Fold up design for easy storage
  • Carbon steel blade
  • Full tang knife design
  • Ring to hang it in your backpack or anywhere else
  • Includes belt pouch
  • It comes razor sharp

Cons:

  • No sheath
  • Does not come with cord, can be bought separately
  • Some issues with rust developing around the hilt
  • Not built for heavy duty use

The Flambeau Outdoors Full Tang Carbon Steel Fixed Blade Knife is perfect as a survival tool; it’s made for people who spend a lot of time in the bush.

Its size of only seven inches makes it ideal for camping or hiking where, as some state, you’ll spend more time hacking than hunting.

You might think that the blade is too heavy, but the steel type and its full tang construction let you use it to cut and not to chop, making it a versatile camp knife.

6. Primos Waggin' Whitetail Deer Decoy

Our rating: 5 / 10

Primos Waggin' Whitetail Deer Decoy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Performs really well in rain
  • A great value for the price
  • The flapping tail looks extremely natural
  • Easy to transport and can be stored easily
  • Solid construction
  • Multiple realistic options
  • Easy to set up

If you’re sick and tired of spending hundreds of dollars on whizbang new gizmos to try and convince a deer to enter your hunting area, you’re going to love the Primos Whitetail Deer Decoy.

Taking a whistle-stop tour of what this deer decoy has to offer, first of all, you’ll love the incredibly realistic motion of the tail.

The fact that it’s a moving tail is going to really add to the lifelike appearance of this decoy.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is it better to use a buck or doe decoy?

Whether you use a real buck or doe decoy will be determined by what you're hunting and where you're hunting. If capturing a mature buck is your objective, then you can often try using a doe decoy to lure him in. If you're trying to get caught a glimpse at mating or to get a great buck shot, then you might want to skip the decoys and just rely on your unseen presence in the woods.

Hang your decoy at least two weeks before your season begins to give it time to gain the scent of an actual deer in the area. Also, hang your decoy where it's not likely to scare away deer from bedding areas or the trail you plan to hunt.

What is the best deer decoy to use?

Deer decoys can be a great strategy for hunting, but the best ones aren’t always 100% realistic. Instead, think about how you can create an area of high interest that will cause deer to pause before entering you area. The goal is not to make deer think they are being tracked by a predator, but to make them curious enough to investigate what the interesting movement is and to want to monitor the movement to see if any danger is imminent.

Different decoys are suitable to different situations. The fake deer calls and urinate are a low-cost option that is good to use when you don’t want to create a total distraction. Instead, you want to quietly add an element of interest that will create movement that a deer can’t resist.

How effective are deer decoys?

The best deer decoys look amazingly life-like and are sure to catch the attention of any deer. The whole point of the deer decoys is that they look like a super-sized food source. And, in large enough numbers, deer decoys can effectively lead deer away from real food sources. Hunters that use deer decoys often report excellent success. However, some hunters also report that deer decoys are not as effective as they are touted to be.

Decoys can certainly be helpful, but it’s not the be-all and end-all of deer control. Fencing and other methods also play an important role in deer management.

Do decoys scare deer?

The answer is complicated. Humans are one of the loudest animals out there and sound travels easily through air and water. That means that the slightest sound can often spook deer. It doesn’t matter if that sound is generated by a dog, a car, or a squirrel, deer are great at picking up on that noise.

Deer also have excellent hearing and some claim that they can hear things from over a mile away. While it’s not quite the range of the blue whale, it’s still pretty impressive! That said, deer are also very good at gauging your intentions based on sound and movement.

Conclusion

In 2019!

We have chosen some of the best deer decoy brands to feature here, and then elaborated on the best attributes across each one. However, after giving them all a close look, we developed a clear favorite. If you want more insight into your own criteria or just want to see the top pick, then you can click on any of the following links to jump to where you want:

To get an idea of how deer decoys work and what to look for, then please read this, our Deer Decoy Buying Guide. For even more details, please continue reading below.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
MONTANA DECOY Dream Team Buck and DoeBest OverallMONTANA DECOY Dream Team Buck and Doe
MONTANA DECOY Miss MuleyBudget PickMONTANA DECOY Miss Muley
Flambeau OutdoorsUpgrade PickFlambeau Outdoors